Press Coverage
Programmes
Press Coverage
Programmes

Originally published in Insurance Asset Management (Physical Copy).
Insurers have yet to enter the defined benefit (DB) pension superfund market, but if they did, could they improve retirement outcomes by investing in a wider range of UK assets? David Adams examines the commercial and regulatory questions that must first be resolved.

One of the many useful things the insurance industry does is run the bulk purchase annuity (BPA) market, offering employers an opportunity to transfer the risks and liabilities linked to defined benefit (DB) pension schemes to insurers via de-risking transactions, including full scheme buyouts. This market is booming in the UK: bulk annuity deals worth £10.2bn were completed during the first half of 2026 alone, according to figures published by Hymans Robertson in September, with the consultancy predicting increased activity during the second half of the year. There are more than 5,000 DB schemes, managing assets collectively worth more than £1.3trn, that are likely to need some kind of endgame solution at some point within the next 10 to 20 years. But within the next few years we may see more schemes following a different path: consolidation into a DB superfund, a larger, purpose-built scheme with its own trustees and advisers.
In theory, this should be a lower cost option, but it is currently only permitted by The Pensions Regulator (TPR) if a scheme passes the “gateway tests”, including a judgment that the scheme is not well enough funded to work towards a buy-out. There are also other endgame solutions available, such as M&G’s insurer-backed run-on solution for well-funded DB schemes, which was launched in October 2026. Today the superfund market is still very small. Until October 2026 the only superfund provider to have passed TPR’s assessment process was Clara, which offers a superfund proposition designed to act as a sort of bridging arrangement leading to full buy-out in the longer term, and which has completed a handful of consolidation deals during the past three years. But in October, another provider, TPT Retirement Solutions, completed the regulatory assessment process.
Its superfund will run schemes on through the endgame, allowing scheme members to benefit throughout their retirement from investment in more diversified, risk-bearing asset classes than would be permitted by a bulk annuity provider. Government and regulators are now developing a full legal and regulatory framework for DB superfunds which should encourage further market growth, supported by recent and forthcoming pensions and financial services legislation. There is also now a school of thought within the insurance and pensions industries, and among some policymakers, that one way to boost growth of the superfund market and open up the potential benefits consolidation could offer to a larger number of schemes, would be to enable full participation in this market by PRA-authorised life insurers.
In September 2026, during the House of Lords debate on the Financial Services and Markets Bill, longstanding campaigner, former pensions minister and non-affiliated peer, Baroness Ros Altmann, tabled an amendment to the Bill that would enable PRA-authorised life insurers to establish, own or operate DB superfunds, directly or through another company within the same group. The amendment proposed strict legal, financial and operational separation between a superfund and an insurer’s core activities. Baroness Altmann told the Lords that insurers “are ideally placed to run large pools of pension investment, with existing in-house expertise in areas such as investment, actuarial and legal,” and that their involvement in the superfunds market could “add billions of pounds-worth of productive capital into the UK economy”, while “scheme members would have better upside opportunities”. She suggested that the superfunds the insurers create could develop into a UK version of the Maple Eight, the eight largest pension funds in Canada, which exert significant influence in that country’s financial system and economy.
Responding for the government, Lord Pitt-Watson said that insurers can already establish and operate superfunds under the existing regulatory framework (technically correct, although in practice extremely unlikely at present), so the primary effect of the amendment would be to embed regulatory and capital requirements for insurers in primary legislation, and these matters would be more appropriately overseen by regulators. Baroness Altmann asked if she might meet a pensions minister to discuss these issues in more depth and Lord Pitt-Watson agreed either to meet her himself, or to arrange a meeting with another minister. Baroness Altmann tells Insurance Asset Management that she has since written to the minister seeking further discussion of this subject with him or a ministerial colleague, but at the time of writing had not yet received a reply.
The amendment was rejected by the Lords, but its aims have supporters in the pensions, investment and insurance industries. They include experts working for New Capital Consensus (NCC), a thinktank backed by a coalition of organisations seeking to reform the UK investment system, to ensure capital is used productively to benefit the economy and savers. “You could have far more risk-bearing investment,” says NCC’s chair and founding director, Ashok Gupta, who is also chair of Mercer UK, and a non-executive director of Sun Life Financial. “I think the point is, buyout starts de-risking schemes 20 years too early. … [Enabling insurers to run superfunds] is beneficial for sponsors and the economy, and for members as well, because they should share in the investment returns. “If the government were to say ‘Let’s incentivise schemes to go into superfunds’, then you could consolidate the £1.3trn currently spread across 5,000 DB schemes. A large part of that could go into 15 to 20 superfunds that would have the ability to invest longterm in real assets, particularly in the UK.” Baroness Altmann also challenges the idea that buyout guarantees the safety of pension benefits.
“The purpose of the amendment was to try to move away from the one-track endgame we are currently on, which gives me significant concern, particularly with the volume of annuities being offshored,” she says. “There is an underlying view that [BPA transactions] are 100% safe. I’m not convinced that that is a wholly correct long-term view. Ultimately, [these annuities are] underwritten by the industry, not government. If a major annuity provider folded, could the FSCS honour the full extent of commitments to its DB liabilities? “I wanted to open up the discussion on whether the current perceptions are correct, or whether the government could recognise the value of having a broader range of solutions,” she continues. “With a superfund there is an opportunity to benefit the member, for insurers to do more to boost growth, and to reduce the risk associated with more and more bulk buy-outs, and the capacity of the global market to underwrite these things.”
Richard Wellard, partner and head of alternative risk transfer solutions at Hymans Robertson, also thinks bringing more insurers into the superfund market would be beneficial. “Insurers already possess much of the expertise and capabilities, around risk management, asset management, pricing and data that would be needed,” he says. “They’re used to operating large books with long term liabilities.” But he wonders which will be the more common form of superfund approach: the Clara bridge to buy-out, or the TPT run-on model. Standard Life managing director for pensions risk transfer and individual retirement, Claire Altman, thinks many insurers may see the bridge to buyout approach as “the more obvious starting point”. She says insurers would monitor market demand for superfunds carefully. “Insurers will also be aware of contagion risk, and given the potential difficulty in communicating the differences between superfunds and insurance to members, will want to ensure that any superfund failure does not negatively impact perceptions of insurance,” she adds. Those insurers that are currently active in the BPA market may also be wary of the possibility that the development of superfunds might constrict the pipeline of schemes working towards buy-out. “There is a risk of cannibalisation, as insurers already dominate DB endgames through buy-ins and buy outs,” says Chris Rice, head of trustee services at pensions and insurance advisory provider Broadstone. “It is not obvious why they would invest in a model that could divert schemes away from their core insurance solutions, particularly when many are already developing products and investment strategies to support trustees pursuing run-on.
Building a superfund proposition is also not costfree. Insurers would need to develop governance structures, operating models, administration capability and regulatory frameworks, and the commercial return would need to justify that investment. If there were a compelling opportunity, I would have expected at least one major insurer to have shown greater appetite by now.”
But insurers will surely find it easier to participate in this market if legal and regulatory complexities or problems are addressed and resolved. Arguably, the current regulatory framework guiding the establishment of DB superfunds is the primary factor limiting development of this market at present. “If insurers own an asset manager there’s a lot of guidance, procedures and protocols that enable them to understand capital and other compliance requirements, but none of that exists for superfunds,” says NCC’s Gupta. “There’s huge uncertainty about the implications for capital requirements, governance and so on. All of that needs to be put in place before any insurance company is likely to commit to do this.”
“For me, the question is more to do with regulation than with legislation,” says Jonathan Repp, a director at Mercer working within the company’s risk transfer team and leading on consulting around superfunds and capital-backed funding arrangements. “At the moment we’ve got two regulators, PRA and TPR, setting rules in quite different ways. That’s for good reasons, given what they’re looking to achieve, but it does bring some complexity. I think if insurers are … [to participate in] the superfund market, we need to have a debate about how these two regulatory regimes compare: where they need to be consistent and where they need to be different.”
Repp wants to see cross-industry discussions to facilitate construction of an appropriate regulatory regime. He hopes at least some of this engagement will happen as part of the consultation around the regulations that are going to bring the Pension Schemes Act 2026 into force. TPR’s Pensions Reform Roadmap suggests consultations on superfunds will take place in 2027 and 2028. Repp also advocates removal of the gateway tests, which currently mean schemes cannot consolidate into a superfund if they could move towards a buy-out. “I think looking further out, as the superfund market matures and as we iron out those regulatory questions and as trustees get more comfortable with the two markets, will there come a point when we no longer need the gateway tests?” he asks. “Where TPR effectively says to trustees ‘You know the questions to ask, get on with it’, rather than setting out specific tests that have to be met?” Baroness Altmann also thinks that “the idea you should only consider a superfund if you can’t afford buy-out is questionable”.
“Schemes are in surplus now, so there’s an opportunity for doing more productive things with that money,” she says. “There’s room for a scheme to move into a superfund and potentially release some capital back to the scheme and members, depending on the size of the surplus, and at the same time benefitting the economy.” As work on developing and refining regulation and legislation continues, regulators are unwilling to comment at length. The PRA declined to answer some specific questions, but stated that the regulatory framework for DB superfunds currently rests with the government and with TPR. A spokesperson for TPR notes that insurance buy-out and superfunds are different options governed by different regulatory requirements and levels of protection. The spokesperson also states that: “The forthcoming legislation can help support superfunds as a credible option alongside buy-out and run-on, while ensuring members benefits remain properly protected.” It seems we will need to wait until after forthcoming consultations have been completed before either regulator is able to provide much more clarity about the likely future shape of the regulatory regime for superfunds.
Commercial considerations Even once these regulatory questions have been resolved, Repp wonders whether this will be enough to convince many insurers to participate in the superfunds market. “The challenge from an insurer’s perspective is that adding another regulatory regime is going to bring complexity to your governance, to your risk frameworks, to your risk reporting,” he says. “And I think there’s going to be quite a few providers that ask, ‘Is it worth it?’ “It’s a super-competitive insurance market. You expect superfunds to be the cheaper solution, but some insurers have done a really good job of driving pricing down within the flexibility they’ve got in Solvency UK, and that has compressed some of that pricing gap you would expect to see between insurance and superfund. So I think there is a question for insurers as to how much cheaper could they make it if they had a superfund available? “The second thing is that the superfund market is growing fast: we’ve seen the number of deals double in 2026 so far, and there may be more to come. But that is doubling from a very low base.” He notes that, to date, Clara has completed eight deals, worth almost £2bn. “That’s fantastic for the superfund market, but if you look at 2025 alone, the bulk annuity providers did 20 times the amount of business as Clara has ever done. They wrote 375 deals, totalling close to £40bn.
“The superfunds market is growing very fast and it’s a market I believe in very strongly. But it’s still a very, very small part of the risk transfer market. I suspect a lot of providers will look at the flexibilities they’ve got in Solvency UK, look at the size of the superfund market at the moment, and decide that for now they’re better spending their energy doing bulk annuities.” Broadstone’s Chris Rice agrees. “Never say never: an insurer may eventually see value in a superfund as a route to capture schemes that are unlikely to reach buyout in the foreseeable future,” he says. “But I struggle to see this becoming a major strategic focus for insurers any time soon.” Schemes in surplus are most likely to consider the BPA option first, Repp suggests, but he thinks this could change, if trustees are given more scope to use scheme surpluses in different ways.
“If we start to see trustees becoming more comfortable using that surplus, to increase member benefits, or potentially returning money to the employer, then some of those surpluses will reduce in size, and that may open the door to more superfund transactions,” he explains. Standard Life sees insurer involvement in DB superfunds “as one part of a broader evolution of the DB endgame market, rather than a major change in direction for established insurers that already provide buy-in and buyout solutions,” says Altman. “Innovation is welcome, but new models ultimately must demonstrate a clear benefit for schemes and members,” she says. Wellard believes the participation of insurers would act as “a significant catalyst for the superfund market”. “It would bring more operators into the market that have the capability to operate at scale,” he says. “We will see how it all plays out.”